clockworktb showed that he carefully had read the brief and he really succeeded to make our concept and ideas to come alive. He was confident with his chosen direction and did not bombard the design contest with thousands of variants. He could explain solid reasoning for each design detail, which gave further confidence in choosing his design as the winner. The design showed to be very versatile when testing it briefly for further packaging design. He was also very responsive for all questions and delivered what was agreed. 4 stars - because only have experience on logo design, but definitely 5 start potential!