for the contest Abstract logo concepts required - scanned sketches are fine
Submitted design #26
...
Hi!
Ok, just commenting on the speaker part, because that's the only icon I see, and this comp is JUST for the icon...
It's pretty artsy.. but that's ok... if you were to submit JUST the speaker icon part, I would probably give it one star (see my ratings system) because it's clean, sharp, monotone, simple. A speaker to the world... hmm...
As it stands, it's hard to comprehend it with that god awful typeface in the way.
Submitted design #75
...
Hi Jarven,
Sorry, this stupid 99designs interface wasn't showing your design up when I searched for "all designs without feedback", because I'd already replied to your #1.
This is good! Very 43signals! It's a 2.5 star - rounded up.
I think you should try putting this to the left of the logo, which is where it would go. And try a few variations.
I think there could be some big potential in this, if executed right.
Thanks!
Do you see that it is a D and a A?
I will be back with some variations.
Submitted design #210
...
Yes, I did see it is a D and an A.
#210 is okay.. it's a direct rip from 37signals though - I was hoping we could borrow inspiration from that design rather than copy it's elements directly.
Oops! I have done some other logos during the week and when I did yours I did think that I had seen this one before, but I did not think of 37signals... This logo should of course not be in the contest but maybe you can se how "your" logo should look like when "DiyAudio" is to the side. Once again, I am sorry that I copy another logo.