Summary
- Status
- won
- Status Comment
- Congratulations to the winner, Leamyone Design!
- Entries
- 59
- Prize
- $100
- Details
-
A closer look at this contest
- Created:
- Thu, 22 May 2008 15:40:40 +0000
- Ends:
- Sun, 25 May 2008 15:40:40 +0000
- Modified:
- Sat, 24 May 2008 22:19:20 +0000
- Last Feedback:
- Tue, 27 May 2008 18:12:31 +0000
- Comments:
- 18
- Designers:
- 20
- Feedback:
- 90%
- Brief Summary
-
No food in icon... more of a happy thin stick or generic person who has or is losing weight with NO EFFORT. Possibly with the idea of "energy moving"
- Actions
- Badges
Entries highest rated first
-
#47 Winning Design
-
- Label:
- #50
- Entrant:
- By karianneartsy
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #8
- Entrant:
- By Zapper
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #18
- Entrant:
- By gw210
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #16
- Entrant:
- By fiona and thea
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #23
- Entrant:
- By Design Sloth
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #28
- Entrant:
- By Design Sloth
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #49
- Entrant:
- By gw210
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #42
- Entrant:
- By Zapper
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #32
- Entrant:
- By Leamyone Design
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #54
- Entrant:
- By zachdesign
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #33
- Entrant:
- By karianneartsy
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #12
- Entrant:
- By Design Sloth
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #22
- Entrant:
- By Design Sloth
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #7
- Entrant:
- By Zapper
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #13
- Entrant:
- By Design Sloth
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #9
- Entrant:
- By Zapper
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #46
- Entrant:
- By zachdesign
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #14
- Entrant:
- By Design Sloth
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #3
- Entrant:
- By mariah_
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #15
- Entrant:
- By mariah_
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #36
- Entrant:
- By Leamyone Design
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #19
- Entrant:
- By peg770
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #52
- Entrant:
- By karianneartsy
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #37
- Entrant:
- By karianneartsy
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #27
- Entrant:
- By Design Sloth
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #4
- Entrant:
- By JelenaP
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #1
- Entrant:
- By Lexi
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #5
- Entrant:
- By sharky
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #51
- Entrant:
- By knutbert
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #17
- Entrant:
- By gw210
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #26
- Entrant:
- By peg770
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #48
- Entrant:
- By knutbert
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #65
- Entrant:
- By zachdesign
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #69
- Entrant:
- By Inphoar
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #45
- Entrant:
- By gw210
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #60
- Entrant:
- By karianneartsy
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #20
- Entrant:
- By gw210
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #66
- Entrant:
- By chriscubos
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #21
- Entrant:
- By gw210
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #40
- Entrant:
- By helveticaaaaaaaa
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #38
- Entrant:
- By EMcMurrin
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #39
- Entrant:
- By EMcMurrin
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #34
- Entrant:
- By peg770
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #44
- Entrant:
- By gw210
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #35
- Entrant:
- By Leamyone Design
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #41
- Entrant:
- By gw210
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #24
- Entrant:
- By Design Sloth
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #61
- Entrant:
- By Zapper
- Rating:
-
- Label:
- #62
- Entrant:
- By Zapper
- Rating:
Discussion
-
4 and 2/3 are too high fashion and too feminine. we also need to see that the icon has lost weight, is hopeful or is simply tapping on one of the points... #1 is actually simple in that the icon is making it look easy - except that it doesn't convey WHAT was easy
- User
- KarinG
- Comment Date
- Thu, 22 May 2008 23:42:01 +0000
- Avatar

- Badge
- Contest Holder
-
people icons in number 8 is on track... (font is a little much)... 7 is also on the correct path. 9,10,11 have too much going on. However, the S being a person is nice - but not quite weightloss
- User
- KarinG
- Comment Date
- Fri, 23 May 2008 03:37:18 +0000
- Avatar

- Badge
- Contest Holder
-
14 - arrow heads are a good idea but the icon in total is not literal enough
- User
- KarinG
- Comment Date
- Fri, 23 May 2008 12:35:18 +0000
- Avatar

- Badge
- Contest Holder
-
Thank you for your feedback!!! i will improve on the fonts on #8 n post it soon....
- User
- Zapper
- Comment Date
- Fri, 23 May 2008 18:24:39 +0000
- Avatar
- Badge
- Designer
-
I love the ideas... Spend the time on the icons - I can work on fonts, I need the creativity in the icon (unless it really is a part of your icon)....remember that this needs to appeal to all sexes and ages... and we can't be too corporate (it is acupressure after all) but not to fuzzy/girly. Please know you are all doing well and getting on track. We DO want an icon or a double icon (as you can see from ratings.) We believe we will be going with black and red (with gray if needed.) Hopefully the logo will only need 2 colors. I eliminated 13 - but like that it spoke to "tapping" - which is the method we are using - if the person icon could also suggest something tapping - it would be perfect (if not too busy)
- User
- KarinG
- Comment Date
- Fri, 23 May 2008 23:44:38 +0000
- Avatar

- Badge
- Contest Holder
-
Double icon = using the same icon twice. Not sold on this but like it.
- User
- KarinG
- Comment Date
- Fri, 23 May 2008 23:52:07 +0000
- Avatar

- Badge
- Contest Holder
-
I do like 2 "people" if possible... but they should not look like parent/child. Tapping is also about energy moving. So people plus energy moving would be great. (I'm trying to clarify as I see the message interpreted in all your drawings)
- User
- KarinG
- Comment Date
- Sat, 24 May 2008 13:49:14 +0000
- Avatar

- Badge
- Contest Holder
-
I like the black circly/energy things in 50. People are great in 47. 8 and 42's people are still hanging in there as well
- User
- KarinG
- Comment Date
- Sat, 24 May 2008 19:50:19 +0000
- Avatar

- Badge
- Contest Holder
-
I like the person in 23 but I don't see how it would would as 2 people as in 28
- User
- KarinG
- Comment Date
- Sat, 24 May 2008 20:04:34 +0000
- Avatar

- Badge
- Contest Holder
-
3-D and classiness of 46 is nice - but not as on track of the "message"
- User
- KarinG
- Comment Date
- Sat, 24 May 2008 20:05:39 +0000
- Avatar

- Badge
- Contest Holder
-
I REALLY like that the artist in 50 is trying to incorporate "energy" into the icon with the people. Can more artists try to work this is with their people? (without it getting too busy?)
- User
- KarinG
- Comment Date
- Sat, 24 May 2008 22:15:35 +0000
- Avatar

- Badge
- Contest Holder
-
OK - everyone.. I'm in a problem here... I'm choosing between 3.....kariannearts, popcorn and leamyone... so here is my proposal... I can split it 3 ways and have kariannearts work with the elements of all 3 to develop the final logo.
- please confirm that this arrangement is OK with the 3 of you... please also send me where I pay you.
I have emailed 99Designs to see if this is OK - but they have not answered in 3 days so far.
Zapper, you hung in there and did a great job - sorry you are not chosen on this job and I hope you enter more of my contests.
- User
- KarinG
- Comment Date
- Tue, 27 May 2008 18:11:04 +0000
- Avatar

- Badge
- Contest Holder
-
i dont want any elements of my logo to be used for 35.00. I would suggest you find the logo that has the most elements correct, and work with that person to get your logo right. If I am not that person than I do not want my logo "person" showing up in anyone's logo. Thanks...Kylie
- User
- popcorn
- Comment Date
- Tue, 27 May 2008 22:50:31 +0000
- Avatar
- Badge
- Designer
-
obviously. Perhaps others don't respect that... However, your logo doesn't incorporate the elements needed. VERY good person icon in my opinion - but I cannot use it on it's own.. so sorry we cannot come to an agreement - would've been open to other alternatives.
- User
- KarinG
- Comment Date
- Wed, 28 May 2008 00:47:28 +0000
- Avatar

- Badge
- Contest Holder
-
Sorry - popcorn was the background and leamyone was the person icon - these elements do not work with what was presented.... neither is good alone. And you both don't want to work together - I understand though. I don't really want to ask more work from either since the 2 of you together give me exactly what I was looking for - oh well - this has taught me about 99designs. (Perhaps if popcorn had a different person icon.) But the contest is over and I cannot continue to ask. karianne was the best of both elements together - I will make a decision then soon... thank you all for all your extreme talent. if anyone has an idea that is "legal" within 99designs and makes you both happy, I am still open to leamyone person and popcorn background squiggle.
- User
- KarinG
- Comment Date
- Wed, 28 May 2008 00:58:02 +0000
- Avatar

- Badge
- Contest Holder
-
Thanx for acknowledging my work.... I will look out for more of your contests in future... I guess kariannearts and leamyone can fuse their work and come up with a better logo conceptand share the prize money. Good Luck KarinG make a wise choice.
- User
- Zapper
- Comment Date
- Wed, 28 May 2008 01:17:39 +0000
- Avatar
- Badge
- Designer
-
I would just pick an artist you want to work with. I am not going to care if you use the squiggly in the background idea. I cannot possibly stop someone from doing that with their design. Its a squiggle for crying outloud...LOL I am sure that Leamyone can re-produce an S shaped squiggle that is just as attractive :)
- User
- popcorn
- Comment Date
- Wed, 28 May 2008 01:47:20 +0000
- Avatar
- Badge
- Designer
-
Then with popcorn being more than reasonable - Leamyone, are you willing to create the logo I need?
- User
- KarinG
- Comment Date
- Wed, 28 May 2008 13:23:40 +0000
- Avatar

- Badge
- Contest Holder