for the contest PetDoc Logo Design
Regarding design #80
Thanks. The cross seems a bit arbitrary. The dog isn't quite symbolic enough... it's hard to make out from far away. And I think we're leaning towards something with the iconography more integrated into the words/letters themselves – so not a dog behind an 'o,' but a dog that IS an 'o.'
Regarding design #82
Same feedback on the cross – I do like the treatment of this dog better than your other design, but this makes the P a dog's ass. Which isn't ideal.
Regarding design #118
Better. I wish the dog was a bit less dominant. I also have a suspicion it would be hard to make out if much smaller. I don't think we can only have a dog – it's either a dog and cat, a dog and medicine or all three.
Regarding design #145
Still too complicated looking
Regarding design #194
Too 1960s Airstream.
Regarding design #208
Good illustration, but it's still too complicated. I do like the idea of the "c" as a tail.
Regarding design #214
Creative concept... Looks too scribbly as it is now.
Regarding design #220
Love the dog. The green isn't dark enough I don't think.
Submitted design #241
Darker green
Regarding design #241
much better
