for the contest Logo for reverse auction site - Pujalia.com
Submitted design #21
Thanks for the invite.
First concept, we have an hammer used in auctions instead of a "p".
Submitted design #22
Second concept, we have people from many countries (colours change), bidding with their hands.
Hello Shaoren!
Thanks for taking the time to participate in the contest.
I love #21. I love the idea of converting the P in a hammer or mallet. I also love the movement sensation that gives the fact the it's approching the "u" with those speed lines and the overlay on it. The only problem is the hammer is not clear enough. I've shown it around and some people asked what the P was supposed to be. I'm not completely sure of how can we change it into something more clear without loosing the funny look.
Unfortunately, I don't love #22 that much. I think most of our users won't see the people bidding with their hands there. Sorry.
Other positive thing is that I love both color combinations. I think that's the color schema we are looking for.
Please, keep the hard work. I think these 2 first results are great.
Thanks!
Submitted design #23
Updated version.
Yes, #23 is much better. But making it so squared it looses some of the funny thing it had... Maybe you want to try something more rounded like this: http://www.mattonimages.com/imagenes/jpg/sb_57436145.html
Submitted design #24
Another version.
Submitted design #25
variant.
Submitted design #26
Another concept.
Submitted design #27
Variant.
#24 looks great! Congratulations!
#25 is too thick
#26 is also good, but I don't think users will understand the price tag there.
#27 looks much more like a "P", but the hammer looks strange.
Right now, I prefer #24.
If you want to improve it or present some alternative designs, you will be more than welcome.
Thanks!
I think I will work on other concepts to see if there are other ways to illustrate Pujalia.
Submitted design #29
Another concept.
Submitted design #30
-
Submitted design #31
Variant.
#30 isn't too memorable...
#31 looks good (specially the hammer that has now volume) but the text is harder to read... maybe shades should be more subtle.
Also, there is a samll problem with the divison in two semi-words ("puja" + "lia") as these two words separately mean in Spanish "bidding confussion". Maybe we should move to a one color only version.
One more time, thank you very much.
Submitted design #33
Updated version.
Perfect. I don't have more feedback for this version at this moment. Feel free to send any update you'd like or, if you like, other concepts. Thanks.